Film Review – Ebenezer
The talent assembled for Ebenezer (2026) feels like a mish mash of names that were randomly selected from a Bingo machine. We have Rupert Grint, Ian McKellen, Daisy Ridley, Sam Caflin, Andrea Riseborough, and Tramell Tillman to name a few. The production is headed by director Ti West, best known for slow-burn horror films like The House of the Devil (2009), The Innkeepers (2011), and the X/Maxine trilogy. And of course, we cannot forget Johnny Depp, in his first major role in almost a decade. Given those involved come from opposite corners of the movie world, it’s surprising how straightforward the result is. This adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic novel A Christmas Carol plays things straight down the line. Some may see that as a relief, others may see it as a missed opportunity to try something different.
Do we really need to go over the details of the story? A Christmas Carol has been adapted so many times that people recognize it through the sheer power of its pop culture influence. We have Ebenezer Scrooge (Depp), his employee Bob Cratchit (Grint), and his dead partner Jacob Marley (McKellen). Mean old Ebenezer gets visited by three spirits all on Christmas Eve: The Ghost of Christmas Past (Riseborough), Present (Tillman), and Yet To Come. Scrooge sees what his life used to be, what it is now, and how he will be remembered (or not remembered) from family and acquaintances. We see him have a change of heart, learn the error of his ways, and committing to a life of charity and goodwill to others. This isn’t spoiler territory – we’ve seen this story play out in all forms of media, from live action, animation, and even with Muppets.

The real question is how well this version presents itself. For the most part, West and his crew (including screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern) stick to the basics. What does stand out is how West incorporates his horror-centric sensibility to the material. This is not an adaptation that is geared for young children. There are some very spooky sequences filled with nightmarish visuals. The cinematography (Checco Varese) and production design (Eve Stewart) construct 19th century London as cold, gloomy, and constantly foggy. The harshness of the environment have affected Scrooge’s very posture. He walks around with his shoulders hunched up to his ears and his arms crossed around his torso. There is an air of dread everywhere, from the cobblestone streets to Scrooge’s small office space. No one looks comfortable. Even when we travel back in time to visit Scrooge as a boy (Alfie Buck) or as a young man (Arthur Conti), no scene ever truly feels warm or inviting.
Two of the film’s biggest accomplishments are in the costuming and make up. This mainly applies to the ghost of Jacob Marley – with the chains of greed weighing him down in the afterlife – as well as the three subsequent ghosts. The design of the specters make them look anything but friendly. They are rendered as horrific beings meant to warn Scrooge to change his ways before it is too late. The Ghost of Christmas Past has pale eyes, stringy white hair, and tattered clothes, making her look like a hellish demon. The Ghost of Christmas Present is mean and bitter. The further along his section goes, the more his body withers, cracks, and chips away like burnt tree bark. There is an element of body horror with The Ghost of Christmas Present (and don’t even get me started on what he has hiding underneath his coat!). The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is not nearly as interesting, as they are depicted as your usual silent Grim Reaper – not too different from what we have seen in other adaptations.
The emotional journey of Ebenezer Scrooge is well known. There isn’t much surprise in terms of where he ends up. The writing/direction tie his character development with the two most important female figures of his life. The first is his sister Molly (Rose Williams), renamed from “Fan” in the novel. Molly was the only person to show kindness to the young Ebenezer and was mother to his nephew Fred (Claflin). The other character is Belle (Ellie Bamber), the single great love of Ebenezer. The scenes between Belle and Ebenezer as young adults start off full of carefree romance, but slowly his obsession over work and money drove a wedge between them. The narrative goes through much effort to show Ebenezer’s gruff personality is due to the guilt he harbors for both Molly and Belle. Yes, we do see his connection to Tiny Tim Cratchit (Freddie Lee-Grey) but that only plays as a minor factor in comparison.

Johnny Depp has been known to play eccentric, quirky, oddball characters. Sometimes, that approach works really well (Edward Scissorhands, Jack Sparrow, Sweeney Todd). Other times it’s a turn off, as though he is simply mugging for the camera just for the sake of being weird (Willy Wonka, The Mad Hatter). Depp plays Scrooge mostly under control, although there were a few times where his hoots and hollers were a little over the top. But when it came time to deliver earnest emotion and show Scrooge’s vulnerable side, Depp delivers. With that said, his choice to play this character at this point in his career does seem like a strategic move. The story of a wealthy man despised by society finding redemption does draw some parallels to Depp’s real life and the legal troubles he went through the last few years. Did he choose this role to get back in the good graces of the mainstream? I’ll leave that for you to decide.
Ebenezer is not the best adaption of A Christmas Carol, nor is it the worst. It is completely and utterly fine. It looks great, has terrific production values, features a strong cast, and pushes the horror elements just enough without going overboard. I was mostly satisfied with what this had to offer, even though it doesn’t do enough to really separate itself from the pack. It’s said that A Christmas Carol has been adapted so many times that there is a version made for just about every generation. I can see younger people attaching to this and making it a yearly holiday watch.
